Google: Site Moves With Redirects In Place Only For 3-Months Is Too Short

We know that Google for several years has been telling us we need to have redirects in place for a year or so for Google to have the site moves stick. But how many months is too few, too little? John Mueller of Google said that three-months for a redirect being on place is not enough and you really need to keep it up for a year.

SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=UCg8P nGCaA | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=yIl2AUoC8zA | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=hl8ANDcrVaY | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=V t1I SPZMU | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=Gu391qSwH A | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=cGdyc7Q 1BI | Craig Hordlow | Craig Hordlow | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=MbsSfiz sEw | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=qj6IDK7rITs | Craig Hordlow