Soft 404s Or Noindex Empty Pages For Google

Michelle Race, aka ShelliWeb, asked an interesting SEO question, she asked what is better for Google when you have empty webpages. Should you noindex the empty webpage or should you let Google index it and treat it as a soft 404?

SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=UCg8P nGCaA | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=yIl2AUoC8zA | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=hl8ANDcrVaY | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=V t1I SPZMU | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=Gu391qSwH A | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=cGdyc7Q 1BI | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?i=uw6b44IwyvA:HmmvBoF0uys:V sGLiPBpWU | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?i=uw6b44IwyvA:HmmvBoF0uys:F7zBnMyn0Lo | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=MbsSfiz sEw | Craig Hordlow SearchEngineRoundtable1?d=qj6IDK7rITs | Craig Hordlow

uw6b44IwyvA | Craig Hordlow